| Year | President | College | Year | President | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1865 | R.A.H. Mitchell | Balliol | 1914 | A. N. S Jackson | B.N.C |
| 1866 | J.H. Forster | University | 1920 | B.G.D.Rudd | Trinity |
| 1867 | B.S. Darbyshire | Wadham | 1921 | B.G.D.Rudd | Trinity |
| 1868 | Earl of Jersey | Balliol | 1922 | E.A. Montague | Magdalen |
| 1869 | J. W. Laing | Christ Church | 1923 | W.R. Milligan | University |
| 1870 | J.H. Morgan | Trinity | 1924 | R.J. Dickinson | Oriel |
| 1871 | R.V. Somers Smith | Merton | 1925 | E.P. Hewetson | Pembroke |
| 1872 | R.H. Benson | Balliol | 1926 | A.E. Porritt | Magdalen |
| 1873 | E.S. Garnier | University | 1927 | A.C. Newman | Christ Church |
| 1874 | W.M. Smith-Dorrien | Magdalen | 1928 | H.M. O’Connor | Trinity |
| 1875 | T. Snow | New College | 1929 | R. Leigh Wood | Trinity |
| 1876 | M.J. Brooks | B.N.C | 1930 | C.E.S. Gordon | Christ Church |
| 1877 | E.R.J. Nicolls | Christ Church | 1931 | H.S. Townend | B.N.C. |
| 1878 | W.H. Grenfell/A. Goodwin | Balliol/Jesus | 1932 | J.F. Cornes | Corpus |
| 1879 | M. Shearman | St. John’s | 1933 | C.J. Mabey | St. Edmund Hall |
| 1880 | A.F. Hills/B.R. Wise | University/Queens | 1934 | J.E. Lovelock | Exeter |
| 1881 | G.P.C. Lawrence | Corpus Christi | 1935 | K.S. Duncan | New College |
| 1882 | G.P.C Lawrence | Corpus Christi | 1936 | F.A.S. Gentry | Christ Church |
| 1883 | T.E. Wells | Magdalen | 1937 | E.B. Teesdale | Trinity |
| 1884 | L. Carter | Corpus Christi | 1938 | A. Pennigton | Hertford |
| 1885 | A. McNeill | Trinity | 1939 | A.W. Selwyn | Jesus |
| 1886 | J.H. Ware | B.N.C | 1946 | P.J.M. Trollope | Balliol |
| 1887 | H.T. Bowlby | Balliol | 1947 | K.H.P. Bailey | St. Peter’s Hall |
| 1888 | F.J.K. Cross | New College | 1948 | P.F.D. Wallis | Trinity |
| 1889 | F.J.K. Cross | New College | 1949 | R.G. Bannister | Exeter |
| 1890 | W. Pollock-Hill | Keble | 1950 | D.M. Dixon | New College |
| 1891 | W.B. Thomas | Christ Church | 1951 | N.D. Stacey | Wadham |
| 1892 | B.C. Allen | Corpus Christi | 1953 | C.J. Chataway | Magdalen |
| 1893 | A. Ramsbottom | Exeter | 1954 | C.E. Villiers | B.N.C. |
| 1894 | C.B. Fry | Wadham | 1955 | C.H. Jeffries | Magdalen |
| 1895 | W.J. Oakley | Christ Church | 1956 | D.J.N. Johnson | Lincoln |
| 1896 | G. Jordan | University | 1957 | D.C.E. Gorrie | Corpus |
| 1897 | G. Jordan | University | 1958 | C.M.G.R. Jenkins | Exeter |
| 1898 | J.M. Freemantle | Hertford | 1959 | R.P.D. Van Rossum | Pembroke |
| 1899 | G.C.Vassall | Oriel | 1960 | J.B. Holt | St. Catherine’s |
| 1900 | A.M. Hollins | Hertford | 1961 | R.A. Lane | B.N.C. |
| 1901 | E.A. Dawson | Worcester | 1962 | R.W. Macklin | B.N.C. |
| 1902 | G.R. Garnier | Oriel | 1963 | A.P. Metcalfe | Magdalen |
| 1903 | A.A. Wilson | Trinity | 1964 | J.M.W. Hogan | Trinity |
| 1904 | T.A. Leach | B.N.C | 1965 | H.H.A. Pullan | New College |
| 1905 | K. Cornwallis | University | 1966 | J.H. Archer | B.N.C. |
| 1906 | K. Cornwallis | University | 1967 | T.M. Taylor | St. Peter’s Hall |
| 1907 | A.H. Fyffe/E.R.J. Hussey | University/Hertford | 1968 | M.A. Hauck | St. Catherine’s |
| 1908 | E.R.J. Hussey | Hertford | 1969 | I.W. Dawes | B.N.C. |
| 1909 | P. Stormonth Darling | New | 1970 | P.A. De Villiers | Trinity |
| 1910 | L.C. Hull | B.N.C. | 1971 | R.A. Steele | New College |
| 1911 | C. Howard Smith | B.N.C | 1972 | B.K. Hull | St. Catherine’s |
| 1912 | G.R.L. Anderson | Trinity | 1973 | P.M.E. Temporal | St. Edmund Hall |
| 1913 | W. Craig Moore | Exeter | 1974 | S.H. White | Wadham |
In 1975, OUAC’s women’s side came into existence. The constitution of the club changed so that whoever was elected as President of OUAC was also the captain of their particular gender. After the President was elected, the opposite gender would then vote in a candidate as their captain.
| Year | President | College | Captain | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1975 | J.N. Goater | S.E.H | L. Wightman | LMH |
| 1976 | A.J. Etchells | St. John’s | M. Willey | St. Hilda’s |
| 1977 | E. Powell | Merton | L. Wightman | LMH |
| 1978 | J.R. Crosse | Magdalen | R. Slator | LMH |
| 1979 | C. Betteridge | Oriel | J. Bramah | St. Hilda’s |
| 1980 | S.J. Walsh | Exeter | J. Reeve | St. Anne’s |
| 1981 | P.A. Clarkson | Queen’s | C. Simpson | St. Anne’s |
| 1982 | A.S. Beardmore | St. Edmund Hall | J. Roynon | Somerville |
| 1983 | J. McCabe | S.E.H | Janet Corlett | St. Anne’s |
| 1984 | G. Clifford | Merton | M. Brennan | Magdalen |
| 1985 | M. Bowen | Balliol | S. Robinson | Jesus |
| 1986 | T. Berrett | B.N.C | V. Pritchard | St. Hugh’s |
| 1987 | J.K.L. Brooke | Balliol | J. Cooke | Jesus |
| 1988 | J.E.D. Crews | Brasenose | M. Higgins | St. Hilda’s |
| 1989 | E. Hobson | Queen’s | S.J. Mugglestone | Hertford |
| 1990 | M.J.Borrett | S.E.H | E. Westlake | St Catherine’s |
| 1991 | S.J.Mugglestone | Keble | J. Latimer | Hertford |
| 1992 | C.F.N. Todd | S.E.H | C. Fisher | Somerville |
| 1993 | S.J. Clarke | St. Hugh’s | G. Karlsson | Merton |
| 1994 | G. Davies | Nuffield | E. Cave | Balliol |
| 1995 | M.J. Weaver | S.E.H | C. May | Queen’s |
| 1996 | S. Rosato | Linacre | C. Martin | Queen’s |
| 1997 | A. Fox | Corpus Christi | J. Street | Pembroke |
| 1998 | T. Costello | LMH | S. Hutchinson | Wolfson |
| 1999 | C. Ridgely | Merton | A. Ireland | Magdalen |
| 2000 | A. Ireland | Magdalen | E. Goodwin | Keble |
| 2001 | C. Sleeman | Queen’s | A-M. Harling | Worcester |
| 2002 | L. C. Chandy | Magdalen | J. Duff | Keble |
| 2003 | M. Rush | Magdalen | H. Edmundson | Regent’s Park |
| 2004 | F. Thompson | Wolfson | A. Wallace | Jesus |
| 2005 | R. Baderin | LMH | K. Sam | Wadham |
| 2006 | N. Radford/M. Bomb | Queens/Magdalen | J. Buckler | St Hugh’s |
| 2007 | S. Marlow | New | F. Smithson | Magdalen |
In 2008, the constitution was changed again, this time so that the club would elect in a President of OUAC, and then both a Men’s Captain and a Women’s Captain. The President stayed as the club’s figure head and leader, with the two captains’ roles now primarily the selection and organisation of their respective Blues teams.
| Year | President | College | Men’s Captain | College | Women’s Captain | College |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 | S. Hughes | Magdalen | P. Duggleby | Brasenose | S. Madgett | Brasenose |
| 2009 | A. Chetwynd | Keble | D. Austin | Balliol | E. Binner | Magdalen |
| 2010 | D. Johnson | New | A. Skouby | Oriel | C. Blättler | University |
| 2011 | C. Witcombe | Keble | B. Horsley | Keble | H. Hanstock | Magdalen |
| 2012 | M. Johnson | Jesus | B. Waldie | Exeter | E. Gatehouse | Christ Church |
